MAT-144 · Mathematical Reasoning Topic 06 · Probability
Lesson 04 · Order · or not

Permutations and combinations.

Permutations count ordered arrangements; combinations count unordered selections. The first question to ask: does swapping two picks give a different answer?

01Order matters? 02P(n, r) · permutations 03C(n, r) · combinations
▸ THE HOOK

Fifty athletes are running a race; medals go to the gold, silver, and bronze finishers. How many ways can the three medals be distributed? L2's counting principle handles this almost directly — 50 choices for gold, but once that's set there are only 49 left for silver, then 48 for bronze. The medals come out to 50 × 49 × 48 = 117,600.

Now flip the question. Same 50 athletes, but instead of medals you're choosing a three-person committee. Three seats, all equal in rank, all interchangeable. The committee {Alice, Bob, Carol} is the same committee no matter which order you pick the members in. How many committees? Definitely fewer than 117,600 — each committee got counted six times by the medal count (once for each of the 3! = 6 orderings). So 117,600 / 6 = 19,600 committees.

The difference between these two problems is the difference between a permutation (order matters, like medals) and a combination (order doesn't, like a committee). Same 50 athletes, same 3 picks, but two very different answers. The first question to ask on any "how many ways" problem is — does swapping two picks change the answer?

Order matters? Permutation. Order doesn't? Combination.

Selecting r items from a pool of n, where each item can be chosen only once, comes in two flavors:

Permutation — order matters. The number of ordered arrangements is P(n, r) = n × (n−1) × ··· × (n−r+1) = n! / (n−r)!.

Combination — order doesn't. The number of unordered selections is C(n, r) = P(n, r) / r! = n! / [(n−r)! · r!].

A combination is always smaller than the corresponding permutation by exactly a factor of r! — the number of ways to reorder r picks. When order doesn't matter, all those reorderings collapse into one selection, so we divide them out.

Both formulas reduce to the counting principle with shrinking choices: 50, 49, 48 for r=3 picks from n=50, and so on.
PERMUTATIONS VS COMBINATIONS does swapping two picks give a different answer? PERMUTATION — ORDER MATTERS 3 medals, distinguishable G S B gold silver bronze choices: 50 × 49 × 48 = 117,600 P(50, 3) = 50! / 47! swap two athletes → different award COMBINATION — ORDER DOESN'T 3 committee seats, interchangeable three identical seats divide by 3! = 6 117,600 / 6 = 19,600 C(50, 3) = 50! / (47! × 3!) swap two members → same committee does swapping change the answer?   →   YES = PERMUTATION   ·   NO = COMBINATION

Left: medals are distinguishable (gold vs silver vs bronze), so a different award assignment is a different arrangement — permutation. Right: committee seats are identical, so swapping two members gives the same committee — combination. The combination count is the permutation count divided by r! = 3! = 6.

▸ DEFINITION

A permutation is an ordered arrangement: P(n, r) = n! / (n−r)!. A combination is an unordered selection: C(n, r) = n! / [(n−r)! · r!]. They differ by the factor r!, which counts the ways to reorder any single selection of r items.

Words you'll see on ALEKS

  • Factorial (n!) n! = n × (n−1) × (n−2) × ··· × 1. So 3! = 6, 4! = 24, 5! = 120, 10! = 3,628,800. By convention, 0! = 1. The factorial counts the number of ways to arrange n distinct items in a row.
  • P(n, r) — permutation Number of ordered ways to pick r items from n: P(n, r) = n × (n−1) × ··· × (n−r+1), which is r terms total. Equivalently, n!/(n−r)!. Use when the position or identity of each pick matters.
  • C(n, r) — combination Number of unordered ways to pick r items from n: C(n, r) = P(n, r) / r!. Use when the order or position doesn't matter and every selection of the same r items is the same answer.
  • The litmus test "Does swapping two of my picks give me a different answer?" If yes (medals, schedules, podium positions), it's a permutation. If no (committees, card hands, pizza toppings), it's a combination. Ask this question first, before reaching for any formula.
  • Shrinking product The descending multiplication n × (n−1) × (n−2) × … that shows up in every permutation. P(10,3) = 10 × 9 × 8 = 720. Stop after r factors. The factorial is just the shrinking product all the way down to 1.

Distributing three medals to 50 athletes.

Direct from ALEKS Q4(a). 50 athletes, 3 distinct medals, no ties. Each medal is different, so order matters — this is a permutation.

"50 athletes are running a race. A gold medal is to be given to the winner, a silver medal to the second-place finisher, and a bronze medal to the third-place finisher. Assume that there are no ties. In how many possible ways can the 3 medals be distributed?"

1

Apply the litmus test.

If athletes Alice, Bob, and Carol finish 1st-2nd-3rd, that's a different outcome than Carol-Alice-Bob finishing 1st-2nd-3rd. The order changes who gets which medal. Order matters — this is a permutation.

→ permutation, not combination
2

Identify n and r.

Picking 3 medalists out of 50 athletes: n = 50, r = 3.

3

Compute the permutation.

P(50, 3) is the product of r = 3 shrinking choices starting from n = 50:

P(50, 3) = 50 × 49 × 48

Compute in two steps:

50 × 49 = 2,450
2,450 × 48 = 117,600

Just over a hundred thousand possible medal distributions for a single 50-athlete race.

→ multiply 3 shrinking choices

Three problems. Litmus test first.

Same setup, three flavors. Ask "does order matter?" first, then pick the right formula.
PROBLEM 01 ☆ ☆   permutation · ALEKS Q4(b)

Aldo has 15 European cities he'd like to visit. On his next vacation, he has time for only 3: one on Monday, one on Tuesday, one on Wednesday. He won't visit the same city twice. How many different schedules are possible?

schedules =
PROBLEM 02 ★ ★ ☆   combination · committee

A club has 12 members and wants to select a 3-person subcommittee (no titles — all three roles are equal). How many different subcommittees are possible?

committees =
PROBLEM 03 ★ ★ ★   litmus test

A pizzeria has 10 toppings. How many different 3-topping pizzas can be made? (All toppings are added at once; the order doesn't matter.)

pizzas =

Three fast questions before you move on.

Tap an answer. Feedback shows up immediately.

Q1. Which scenario is a permutation (order matters)?

Why C? The three places are distinguishable — swapping the 1st and 2nd runner gives a different result. The other three (books, hand, toppings) are unordered selections — same set, no matter the pick order → combinations.

Q2. Compute P(8, 2).

Why C? P(8, 2) = 8 × 7 = 56. Two shrinking choices starting from 8. B (28) is C(8, 2) — the combination answer (56 / 2! = 28).

Q3. Why is C(n, r) always ≤ P(n, r) for r ≥ 1?

Why B? Combinations are permutations divided by r! (which counts the redundant reorderings). Since r! ≥ 1 for any r ≥ 0, the combination count is always at most the permutation count — with equality only when r = 0 or r = 1 (so r! = 1).
▸ UP NEXT — LESSON 05

Order is the question; everything else follows.

Most counting questions in life are one of these two flavors. Sports lineups (permutation: batting order matters), poker hands (combination: 5 cards is 5 cards regardless of dealing order), lottery picks (combination: 6 numbers is 6 numbers), passwords (permutation: ABCD ≠ DCBA), committee assignments (combination: three interchangeable seats), seating arrangements (permutation: chair 1 ≠ chair 2).

Once you train your eye for the litmus test, the formulas become rote: pick r out of n, multiply the shrinking choices, and divide by r! if order doesn't matter.

Next: Lesson 5 introduces expected value — turning the probabilities and counts we've built so far into an average payout. The math behind fair games, insurance premiums, and the casino's edge.

Continue to Lesson 05

Different angle? Need another rep? These are optional — tap any that look helpful.

▸ Browse all Topic 6 resources